
American law was bred from British law. Our original colonists, and our forefathers who created the United States, came from a land where the King, or Royal leader, was immune from being sued. This concept is called “sovereign immunity”.
While states, municipalities, and the federal government were originally granted the same protection, these entities have tended to voluntarily agree to waive such total immunity, but with very strict guidelines. While sovereign immunity in Florida refers to the state’s authority to exempt itself from civil lawsuits, the state does permit negligence claims to be asserted against it and its subdivisions (agencies, cities, counties, and public hospitals) but only pursuant to the terms it creates. And these terms provide for significant financial limits-even in cases where the injured party has suffered catastrophic injuries, and incurred millions of dollars in damages.
When I passed the Florida bar examination in 1989, Florida had limited its liability in these cases to merely $100,000. Thereafter, in 2010, the legislature increased this cap so injured parties can currently sue for damages and collect within the liability thresholds set at $200,000 per individual and $300,000 per incident. When a claimant garners a verdict and judgment that exceeds these limits, that claimant must petition the legislature in the form of a “claims bill” to collect the amount in excess of the cap. This is an exhausting and expensive political process that is, more often than not, unsuccessful for the claimant. Once a claims bill is filed, each chamber’s presiding officer refers it to a special master, who essentially reconsiders the jury’s recommendation. That allows the defendant to challenge the jury verdict.
Claims bills are also presented to Florida House and Senate committees that consider special masters’ recommendations. Ultimately, the bills must pass in both chambers.
Recently, House Bill 145 was passed in March 2026 to increase the sovereign immunity caps to $350,000 per individual and $500,000 per incident. But, thereafter, Governor Ron DeSantis announced that he intended to veto this legislation that would help people sue state and local government bodies, saying it would also increase the number of “unmeritorious” damages lawsuits. He suggested that the more important concern was to reduce local government costs and provide residents with lower property taxes.
On June 30, 2026, DeSantis officially vetoed the legislation.

The Florida Hospital Association, the largest hospital association in the state, commended this veto indicating that the governor’s decision was “preserving the legal framework that allows Florida’s publicly operated hospitals to continue caring for their communities and fulfilling the governmental obligations placed upon them.” Meanwhile, Floridians lose mothers, fathers, husbands, wives, and children, or suffer life-altering injuries, because of governmental and medical negligence.
From my perspective as a trial lawyer committed to fight negligence and hold physicians and facilities responsible for medical malpractice, I think the Governor’s decision has shown that once again, insurance companies and financially sophisticated institutions have prevailed over Florida families who simply want accountability.
For years, board certified civil trial lawyer and board certified medical malpractice lawyer attorney Jeffrey "Jack" Gordon has challenged the legal obstacles facing people who are injured on tribal casino property. His criticism is not simply about individual claims but about a broader system that, in his view, allows the Seminole Tribe of Florida to act as the ultimate decision-maker when negligence allegations arise against its own operations.
The issue gained attention following the 2007 death of Annie Talley, a regular patron of the Seminole Hard Rock Hotel & Casino near Tampa. Talley suffered cardiac arrest while visiting the casino and died two days later. Her family later sought records that they believed could clarify how quickly emergency personnel responded and what measures were taken to save her life.
Their search for answers led them to a legal doctrine that has long been a source of debate: tribal sovereign immunity.
As a federally recognized tribe, the Seminole Tribe of Florida enjoys sovereign immunity protections that generally prevent lawsuits from proceeding unless immunity has been expressly waived or Congress authorizes such actions.
As a result, patrons who believe they were harmed on tribal property often face legal barriers that would not exist in claims against traditional commercial businesses. While the Tribe has historically resolved some claims through its insurance process, those claims typically do not proceed before independent judges or juries.
That lack of independent review is one of Gordon's primary concerns.
Gordon has handled approximately a dozen claims involving the Seminole Tribe and has acknowledged that, in many instances, settlements were reached when liability appeared clear. He has even stated that the Tribe's insurance adjusters and attorneys often "do the right thing" when the facts support a claim.
Still, Gordon argues that the process itself is flawed because the Tribe ultimately controls the decision-making process. He believes allowing the tribe to self-regulate and decide whether or not they deem a claim worthy seems like a conflict of interest.
"The same guys that I'm accusing of wrongdoing, they're going to make the decision of whether there's wrongdoing? That's not fair."
For Gordon, the issue is not simply whether claims are paid. It is whether injured individuals have access to a neutral forum that can independently evaluate evidence and determine liability in a fair and just manner.
In another case, Gordon represented Christopher Robertson, who alleged that casino security personnel failed to adequately protect him during an assault at the Seminole Hard Rock Casino in Tampa.
To pursue that claim, Gordon relied on language contained in a gaming compact between the Seminole Tribe and the State of Florida. He argued that the compact created a limited waiver of sovereign immunity for certain personal injury claims. Although portions of that compact later became the subject of legal disputes, Gordon maintained that once immunity is waived, it remains waived. As Gordon explained:
"Once you waive it, it's waived. We'll see how it plays out."
The lawsuit reflected Gordon's effort to test the boundaries of sovereign immunity and create greater access to the courts for individuals injured on tribal property.
The questions raised by the Talley and Robertson matters remain relevant today. Tribal sovereignty is an important legal principle, but critics such as Gordon argue that customers of large commercial casino operations should have access to independent legal review when serious injuries or deaths occur.
Whether through legislative action, court rulings, or negotiated agreements, Gordon has consistently argued for a system in which claims are evaluated by neutral decision-makers rather than solely through internal processes.
His position remains straightforward: when allegations of negligence arise, fairness requires more than self-regulation. It requires an independent forum where the facts can be fully examined and the merits of a claim can be decided by someone other than the accused party itself.
